PARTICIPATING RESTAURANTS
Hoagies & Hops / Chilly Water Taproom
Check out the only authentic PA Hoagie & Philly Cheesesteak Shop in Indy partnering with Chilly Water Brewery! We Now have 2 Locations! Find our Family Friendly Location in the Butler Tarkington Neighborhood or 21 & Over Location in Fletcher Place Neighborhood.
What makes us so special? The Owner is from Southeast PA and a Penn State Grad! She takes pride in sourcing rolls from S. Jersey, along with Cold cuts and Snacks shipped in from the PA Dutch country & Philly to give you that true PA Grub experience! You can also try PA Herrs Potato Chips, Smoked Lebanon Bologna, Red Beet Pickled Eggs, Vegan/GF Options, Salads, Pickle Hoagies and More!
Closed Mondays
Family Friendly at our Butler Tarkington Location.
Patios at Both Locations
Menu available for Dine in, Take Out or Curbside.
Lunch - Dinner
Catering Available Everyday!
4155 Boulevard Pl, Indianapolis, IN 46208
(317) 426-5731 - Butler Tarkington
Tuesday - Sunday: 11a-9p
Additional Menu Options: Gluten-free, Vegetarian, Vegan
$13/ PERSON UP to $17/Person with Chilly Water Beer
7” Cheesesteak or Chicken Cheesesteak, Cold Hoagie or Vegan Italian Sausage
Includes:
*Crinkle Cut Fries, Herr’s Chips, Potato Salad, Coleslaw, or Creamy Cucumber Salad
*Chocolate Chip Cookie or Mini Boulevard Oreo Cheesecake Ball made in house
Fountain Drink Or
$17 with a Chilly Water Pint from the tap room
CHEESESTEAKS
CHEESESTEAK – Wit or Wit Out Fried Onions – Cheese Whiz, American, Provolone or Sharp
CHICKEN CHEESESTEAK – Wit or Wit Out Fried Onions – Cheese Whiz, American, Provolone or Sharp
*We Charge for Extra Toppings
COLD HOAGIES
HOG ISLAND – Black Forest Ham, Capicola, Salami, Prosciutto, Provolone, LTOO
SHIPYARD – House Tuna, Provolone, Peppadew Peppers, Parm, LTOO
KEYSTONE – London Broil, Provolone, Horseradish Mayo, LTO
ALWAYS SUNNY – D&W Turkey, Smoking Goose Bacon Bits, Horseradish Mayo, Banana Peppers, Peppadew Peppers.
CLASSIC HAM OR TURKEY – Cheese Choice, Sauce Choice topped w/ LT
| Veggie or No Bread Option
*Pickle Hoagies – Have any hoagie or cheesesteak inside a Whole Deli Pickle *Have any hoagie on a bed of lettuce *Vegan Italian Sausage – Sauteed Onions, Sweet Bell Peppers, House Spicy Red Sauce on a bun |
$13/ PERSON UP to $17/Person with Chilly Water Beer
7” Cheesesteak or Chicken Cheesesteak, Cold Hoagie or Vegan Italian Sausage
Includes:
*Crinkle Cut Fries, Herr’s Chips, Potato Salad, Coleslaw, or Creamy Cucumber Salad
*Chocolate Chip Cookie or Mini Boulevard Oreo Cheesecake Ball made in house
Fountain Drink Or
$17 with a Chilly Water Pint from the tap room
CHEESESTEAKS
CHEESESTEAK – Wit or Wit Out Fried Onions – Cheese Whiz, American, Provolone or Sharp
CHICKEN CHEESESTEAK – Wit or Wit Out Fried Onions – Cheese Whiz, American, Provolone or Sharp
*We Charge for Extra Toppings
COLD HOAGIES
HOG ISLAND – Black Forest Ham, Capicola, Salami, Prosciutto, Provolone, LTOO
SHIPYARD – House Tuna, Provolone, Peppadew Peppers, Parm, LTOO
KEYSTONE – London Broil, Provolone, Horseradish Mayo, LTO
ALWAYS SUNNY – D&W Turkey, Smoking Goose Bacon Bits, Horseradish Mayo, Banana Peppers, Peppadew Peppers.
CLASSIC HAM OR TURKEY – Cheese Choice, Sauce Choice topped w/ LT
| Veggie or No Bread Option
*Pickle Hoagies – Have any hoagie or cheesesteak inside a Whole Deli Pickle *Have any hoagie on a bed of lettuce *Vegan Italian Sausage – Sauteed Onions, Sweet Bell Peppers, House Spicy Red Sauce on a bun |
Veggie or No Bread Option
*Pickle Hoagies – Have any hoagie or cheesesteak inside a Whole Deli Pickle
*Have any hoagie on a bed of lettuce
*Vegan Italian Sausage –
Sauteed Onions, Sweet Bell Peppers, House Spicy Red Sauce on a bun
$13/ PERSON UP to $17/Person with Chilly Water Beer
7” Cheesesteak or Chicken Cheesesteak, Cold Hoagie or Vegan Italian Sausage
Includes:
*Crinkle Cut Fries, Herr’s Chips, Potato Salad, Coleslaw, or Creamy Cucumber Salad
*Chocolate Chip Cookie or Mini Boulevard Oreo Cheesecake Ball made in house
Fountain Drink Or
$17 with a Chilly Water Pint from the tap room
CHEESESTEAKS
CHEESESTEAK – Wit or Wit Out Fried Onions – Cheese Whiz, American, Provolone or Sharp
CHICKEN CHEESESTEAK – Wit or Wit Out Fried Onions – Cheese Whiz, American, Provolone or Sharp
*We Charge for Extra Toppings
COLD HOAGIES
HOG ISLAND – Black Forest Ham, Capicola, Salami, Prosciutto, Provolone, LTOO
SHIPYARD – House Tuna, Provolone, Peppadew Peppers, Parm, LTOO
KEYSTONE – London Broil, Provolone, Horseradish Mayo, LTO
ALWAYS SUNNY – D&W Turkey, Smoking Goose Bacon Bits, Horseradish Mayo, Banana Peppers, Peppadew Peppers.
CLASSIC HAM OR TURKEY – Cheese Choice, Sauce Choice topped w/ LT
Veggie or No Bread Option *Pickle Hoagies – Have any hoagie or cheesesteak inside a Whole Deli Pickle
*Have any hoagie on a bed of lettuce
*Vegan Italian Sausage –
Sauteed Onions, Sweet Bell Peppers, House Spicy Red Sauce on a bun